Song House

Artist Evaluation

Honest feedback from the ones who have walked this road. What you write here helps new artists grow, and helps us build the kind of community we all wish we had when we started.

01The basics

Your name stays between us and Tyler. It is never shared with the artist you are reviewing.

02Score the performance

Go with your gut. 1 means not yet, 10 means this artist made the room stop breathing. There is no wrong answer. Your instinct is the data.

Vibe & Room Energy
Did the air in the room shift when they started? Did they bring something?
flatelectric
Feel & Emotional Pull
Did you feel anything? Did it get into your chest? Was it honest?
nothing movedwrecked me
Vocal Delivery
Tone, control, intention, phrasing. Not just technical. Did their voice serve the song?
roughunforgettable
Stage Presence
Did they own the space? Did they look like they belonged up there?
shrinkingcommanding
Songwriting & Storytelling
Is the song good? Lyric, melody, structure. Would you listen again on purpose?
not yeton repeat
Musicianship
Guitar, piano, arrangement, pocket. How well do they wear their instrument?
shakymasterful
Authenticity
Does this feel like them, or like they are chasing a trend? Is there a real person in there?
performing a costumefully themselves
Artist Identity
Can you describe what kind of artist they are in one sentence? Is the lane clear?
blurrycrystal clear
Crowd Connection
Did the room lean in? Did they look up? Did they share the moment?
closed offlocked in
Coachability & Growth Potential
If Song House poured into them for a year, how far could they go?
cappedlimitless
Song House Fit
Would they make this community better? Do they belong in this room?
not our room100% Song House
X Factor
That thing you cannot name. The reason you would text a friend about them tonight.
none yetundeniable

03The honest part

This is where the gold lives. Be kind. Be real. This is the feedback you wish someone gave you at their age.

Song House Collective · Nashville, TN

Thank you.

Your honesty just made this community better. Tyler will read every word.